I like the finale but there were some things I was upset about, mostly:

-Kara disappearing with no explanation at all? What was she? Just seriously, what? I just hate that my favorite character just disappears. Blah.

I completely agree. I really wanted some closure about her character, it was such a big deal and then just...nothing? really? And I SOO wanted her and Lee to end up together.

I hadn't actually thought about Tigh and Adama, but you're totally right, I can't believe they didn't have a big goodbye scene. They really should have. The goodbyes w/ Lee and Kara made me cry though..."Nothing but the rain"...awww

I can't believe its over!!