Because they have no character love whatsoever. I'm all about the character love. Make me love the characters, find joy in them, laugh, cry, whatever, SOMETHING. I don't find them "scary" and ugh Blink was boring, I just wanted my Doctor and Martha. Everyone raves about how brilliant they are but I don't see anything that indicates that and if I'm too bored to care, who gives a crap? And I love Jack in every episode, no matter who writes him. I've met a few people who agree, butterfly for one and we disagree a lot about DW so it's kind of funny. I don't have a big attachment to DW, with all the change, it's hard plus I don't usually like episodic shows (serial shows-like Heroes when done well are my thing), so I don't mind much, I just hope I can find a little enjoyment in the show. But if not, oh well, I have many others, it's just sad when I disagree with the rest of fandom.

Yes I definitely agree there, I wasn't expecting it to be so smart! True about the personality for the boyfriend, I definitely wish the present time characters would get more personality/screentime. And he's American? Ha I couldn't even tell. I hope there's a second season too! I can't even imagine that being all there is. I want to see him grow up! Although you never know with UK shows. I want to read the book as well, I instantly fell for Simon on Top Design so I'm not surprised I love this. It IS great! I need an icon.